This article was first published in December 2021, as businesses prepared for cyber insurance renewals in 2022. Renewals that season looked noticeably different from earlier years, with more questions about security and tougher terms. This piece looks at what changed around that time, why, and what it still means for a small or mid-sized business.
What happened in 2021
Ransomware dominated the year. On May 7, 2021, a ransomware attack on Colonial Pipeline made headlines around the world, with images of long lines at gas stations. In July 2021, attackers used a flaw in Kaseya’s VSA software to push ransomware to managed service providers and their customers, which CISA covered in its guidance for affected MSPs and their customers.
These incidents showed different sides of the same problem. Colonial Pipeline showed how much disruption one compromised business could cause. Kaseya showed how one compromised supplier could reach a long list of downstream businesses at once. An event like that can lead to claims from many policyholders at the same moment.
How renewals changed
In December 2021, Insurance Business magazine advised brokers and their clients to prepare for rate increases, reduced capacity, ransomware sublimits, coinsurance, higher deductibles and supplemental applications ahead of 2022 renewals. The security measures it said carriers were focusing on were familiar ones: multi-factor authentication across the network, regular employee training, closing remote desktop protocol, completing software patches and updates, and endpoint detection and response tools where budget allowed.
The broker interviewed in that article described renewals that had once been largely a box-checking exercise turning into a longer process, with conversations starting months before the renewal date.
What those policy terms mean
Several of the terms that became common in that period are worth understanding before you sign any renewal. Your policy wording and your broker are the authority on how they apply to you.
- A sublimit caps what the policy will pay for a particular kind of loss, such as ransomware, below the policy’s overall limit.
- Coinsurance means you pay a share of a covered loss yourself, on top of the deductible.
- A supplemental application is an extra questionnaire, often about specific security controls, added to the main application.
- Exclusions and conditions can tie coverage to controls being in place. If the application says a control exists and it does not, that gap can matter when a claim is reviewed.
Why it still matters
The market conditions of 2022 are history, but the lesson carries forward: a cyber insurance application is a set of statements about how your systems are configured, signed by the business. The controls that drew attention in 2021, such as MFA, patching, closing exposed remote access and endpoint detection, are the same basics that make ransomware harder to start and easier to contain.
Two lessons from that period hold up:
- Treat the application as a security review, not paperwork. Have someone who knows your configuration confirm each technical answer before you sign.
- Start early. Changes such as rolling out MFA to every account or replacing an exposed remote access tool take planning, and they are easier to finish before the renewal date than to promise afterward.
For manufacturers, who were the focus of this article’s original series, the same applies to plant systems as well as office IT. Our manufacturing page covers both.
What to do next
Find your most recent cyber insurance application and policy. Check each technical answer against your current setup, and ask your broker to explain any sublimits, coinsurance or security conditions in the policy. Our cybersecurity services page describes the controls involved, and you can request a Blind Spot Scan for an outside view of where you stand before your next renewal.